Now is the time to kill House Bill 2504. Here’s how Editorial Pages Editor Wayne Greene says you can help.
Oklahoma’s legislative process has a number of built-in brakes to stop good bills and bad.
The first and most effective killer of legislation is the committee process. Bills are routinely assigned to committees and, under the normal rules, need the committee’s endorsement to move forward. That means a committee chairman can kill a proposal simply by never giving it a hearing. Or it can get a hearing and be voted down.
In 2011, I analyzed a year’s worth of introduced legislation and found that in the state House, 78.7% of bills that didn’t make it into law either didn’t get a hearing in committee or were rejected in committee. In the Senate, 74.7% of unsuccessful bills didn’t get past the initial committee process. Those numbers will vary from year to year, but every year, a lot of legislation gets left at the starting line.
People are also reading…
While the biggest test for most legislation is the first one, the most critical moment in the legislative process comes later: As in right now.
The House has passed all the bills written by representatives — House bills — that it’s going to consider this year, and the Senate has passed all the Senate bills. All those House bills have traveled across the Capitol rotunda to the Senate to start over in another committee. Same thing, opposite direction for the Senate bills. Both chambers must approve the exact same language for a bill to proceed.
A few years ago, at about this moment in the process, a top legislative leader told a Tulsa Regional Chamber breakfast that it’s time for the House leadership to kill all the bad ideas sent over by the Senate, and the Senate to kill all the bad ideas sent over by the House.
It was a moment of honesty that reflected what happens almost every year.
There are a lot of bills that are still live rounds that most legislators and probably the leadership know wouldn’t be good for the state, although they may have voted for some of them.
The bills survived because the leadership couldn’t afford politically to be against them or needed the author’s support on some other issue. They’re counting on those bad-idea bills to disappear into the dark recess of the opposite chamber.
There are a lot of bad ideas out there.
House Bill 2504 would strip Tulsa and Oklahoma county health departments of much of their independence but still expect Tulsa and Oklahoma county taxpayers to foot the bill. It’s a bad bill, but it made it through the House. It’s time for the Senate to lose it.
Passing the buck to the other chamber is a dangerous game. Bad ideas sometimes become bad laws.
That’s where ordinary citizens can make a huge difference.
When I first wrote about HB 2504 I got several emails from readers who wanted to know what they could do.
It may sound trite, but the answer is: Call your legislators. Email them, too.
You can find out who your legislator is by using a tool at the bottom of the state House home page: okhouse.gov. The site will link you to telephone numbers and email addresses.
Call the Capitol. Know what you’re going to say before you dial the phone. Ask to speak to the legislator, but be willing to leave your message with the legislative assistant. Part of that person’s job is to report on constituent calls. Be brief, friendly and honest. Say that you are a voting constituent. Let them know that you are paying attention to this issue, and what you think should be done. If the legislative assistant offers to have your legislator return the call, accept it.
Then email the same message.
Then tell your friends to do the same.
I’ve been told by Republicans and Democrats in the House and Senate that five genuine contacts from constituents on a single bill is a groundswell of interest. Ten is an overwhelming groundswell. They pay attention.
Two Tulsa County senators, Dave Rader of Tulsa and John Haste of Broken Arrow, could make a big difference on the health department bill. They’re both reasonable Republicans who Senate President Pro Tem Greg Treat needs to listen to. Haste is on the Senate Health and Human Services Committee. HB 2504 hasn’t been assigned, but that committee seems like a likely landing spot.
Sen. Jo Anna Dossett of Tulsa is on that committee, too, although as a Democrat she doesn’t have the clout of a Rader or a Haste. If you live in her district, tell her what you think.
If you have friends in Oklahoma City, get them to contact Treat. He’s a reasonable guy, and the Oklahoma County Health Department’s independence is at risk, too.
The chairman of the Health and Human Services Committee is Greg McCortney of Ada. I always caution people against calling legislators from other districts. Nonconstituent phone calls are discounted heavily. But if you know people from Ada, get them to call McCortney. Have them mention that the state Health Department has more money to spend in Pontotoc County because the Tulsa and Oklahoma County departments are essentially self-supporting.
This isn’t the only time to kill HB 2504, but it’s the most opportune time, because it can be done quietly by a few people. The longer a bad idea hangs around, the more likely it is to become a bad law.
Word of the day: realpolitik — a word that rose from 19th-century Germany to describe governmental and diplomatic moves based on realistic pragmatism rather than ideals. Otto von Bismarck and Lyndon Johnson have been described as masters of the craft by admirers and critics.
Tulsa-area state legislators and how to contact them
Tulsa-area state legislators and how to contact them
Sen. Nathan Dahm
DISTRICT 33
Sen. Nathan Dahm (R)
Hometown: Broken Arrow
District area: South and east Tulsa County
Phone: 405-521-5551
Sen. Dana Prieto
DISTRICT 34
Sen. Dana Prieto (R)
Hometown: Tulsa
District area: Owasso and northern Tulsa County
Phone: 405-521-5566
Email Sen. Prieto
Sen. Jo Anna Dossett
DISTRICT 35
Sen. Jo Anna Dossett (D)
Hometown: Tulsa
District area: South and central Tulsa
Phone: 405-521-5624
Sen. John Haste
DISTRICT 36
Sen. John Haste (R)
Hometown: Broken Arrow
District area: Eastern Tulsa County, western Wagoner County
Phone: 405-521-5602
Email Sen. Haste
Sen. Todd Gollihare
DISTRICT 12
Sen. Todd Gollihare (R)
Hometown: Kellyville
District area: Creek County
Phone: 405-521-5528
Sen. Kevin Matthews
DISTRICT 11
Sen. Kevin Matthews (D)
Hometown: Tulsa
District area: Northern Tulsa, southeast Osage County
Phone: 405-521-5598
Sen. Joe Newhouse
Newhouse
Sen. Dave Rader
DISTRICT 39
Sen. Dave Rader (R)
Hometown: Tulsa
District area: Central and south Tulsa
Phone: 405-521-5620
Sen. Cody Rogers
Rogers
Rep. Meloyde Blancett
DISTRICT 78
Rep. Meloyde Blancett (D)
Hometown: Tulsa
District area: Midtown Tulsa
Phone: 405-557-7334
Rep. Jeff Boatman
DISTRICT 67
Rep. Jeff Boatman (R)
Hometown: Tulsa
District area: Southeast Tulsa
Phone: 405-557-7341
Rep. Amanda Swope
DISTRICT 71
Rep. Amanda Swope (D)
Hometown: Tulsa
District area: Brookside in Tulsa
Phone: 405-557-7361
Rep. Suzanne Schreiber
DISTRICT 70
Rep. Suzanne Schreiber (D)
Hometown: Tulsa
District area: Midtown Tulsa
Phone: 405-557-7359
Email Rep. Schreiber
Rep. Dean Davis
DISTRICT 98
Rep. Dean Davis (R)
Hometown: Broken Arrow
District area: Elm Place in east Broken Arrow, east to 248th East Avenue
Phone: 405-557-7362
Rep. Mark Tedford
DISTRICT 69
Rep. Mark Tedford (R)
Hometown: Tulsa
District area: Jenks, Bixby and Tulsa between those cities
Phone: 405-557-7331
Rep. Scott Fetgatter
DISTRICT 16
Rep. Scott Fetgatter (R)
Hometown: Okmulgee
District area: Okmulgee County and the southeastern tip of Tulsa County
Phone: 405-557-7373
Rep. Ross Ford
DISTRICT 76
Rep. Ross Ford (R)
Hometown: Broken Arrow
District area: West Broken Arrow
Phone: 405-557-7347
Rep. Regina Goodwin
Goodwin
Rep. Kyle Hilbert
DISTRICT 29
Rep. Kyle Hilbert (R)
Hometown: Depew
District area: Westernmost Tulsa County, Creek County
Phone: 405-557-7353
Rep. Mark Lawson
DISTRICT 30
Rep. Mark Lawson (R)
Hometown: Sapulpa
District area: Sapulpa, Mounds, southwest Tulsa County
Phone: 405- 557-7414
Rep. T.J. Marti
DISTRICT 75
Rep. T.J. Marti (R)
Hometown: Tulsa
District area: East Tulsa
Phone: 405-557-7356
Rep. Stan May
DISTRICT 80
Rep. Stan May (R)
Hometown: Broken Arrow
District area: Southeast Tulsa County; small section of southwest Wagoner County
Phone: 405-557-7338
Rep. Monroe Nichols
DISTRICT 72
Rep. Monroe Nichols (D)
Hometown: Tulsa
District area: Southeast corner of Inner Dispersal Loop to Owasso; also includes Turley and Sperry
Phone: 405-557-7391
Rep. Clay Staires
Staires
Rep. Terry O'Donnell
DISTRICT 23
Rep. Terry O’Donnell (R)
Hometown: Catoosa
District area: Catoosa, east Tulsa
Phone: 405-557-7379
Rep. Melissa Provenzano
DISTRICT 79
Rep. Melissa Provenzano (D)
Hometown: Tulsa
District area: East and southeast Tulsa
Phone: 405-557-7330
Rep. Lonnie Sims
DISTRICT 68
Rep. Lonnie Sims (R)
Hometown: Tulsa
District area: West Tulsa County from the bend of Arkansas River down to Glenpool
Phone: 405-557-7340
Rep. John Kane
DISTRICT 11
Rep. John Kane (R)
Hometown: Bartlesville
District area: Bartlesville, north Tulsa County including Collinsville
Phone: 405-557-7358
Rep. Mark Vancuren
DISTRICT 74
Rep. Mark Vancuren (R)
Hometown: Owasso
District area: Suburban Owasso
Phone: 405-557-7377
Rep. John Waldron






