Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Archaeologists uncover additional coffin as researchers close excavation at Oaklawn Cemetery

Archaeologists uncover additional coffin as researchers close excavation at Oaklawn Cemetery

  • Updated
  • 0

An 11th coffin has been found in a trench in Oaklawn Cemetery, researchers looking for unmarked burials from Tulsa’s 1921 Race Massacre said Thursday.

The trench, dug Wednesday and Thursday, covers about a third of a subsurface anomaly, said State Archaeologist Kary Stackelbeck. That, she said, suggests the possibility that more remains could be found.

But that will have to wait until next year. The researchers decided to close the site in the southwest corner of Oaklawn Cemetery, fill in the trench and pursue legal authority to exhume the fragile remains.

Between that and the onset of winter, the researchers said, work at the site is unlikely to resume until spring.

The excavation is in an area thought to be a likely burial spot for 18 Black men killed in the massacre. Stackelbeck, though, said one of the 11 coffins found in the trench might not belong with the others.

“We have one individual who appears to be intrusive, that we encountered at a higher depth ... and in a different style coffin,” Stackelbeck said at an afternoon briefing. “We believe that individual represents a subsequent burial” on top of the others.

But Stackelbeck said the team cannot rule out coffins being stacked more than one deep in the trench. The unevenness of the burials suggest such a possibility, she said.

Stackelbeck said the last coffin discovered is at the extreme west end of the trench, fitted in beside steps that appear to have been cut into the soil a century ago to facilitate the handling of the coffins. The coffins in the trench are otherwise arranged in pairs.

The western and southern extent of the anomaly was reached by the excavation, Stackelbeck said, and the northern boundary identified. It is possible, she said, that the target area may extend a little farther east.

None of the remains uncovered were marked by headstones.

Forensic anthropologist Phoebe Stubblefield said the first remains uncovered, in a single grave shaft a few feet from the trench, are those of a woman. That’s significant because the original 18 were all identified as men on their death certificates and no death certificate for a woman killed in the massacre has ever been found.

Thus, this woman’s remains are either unrelated to the massacre or are the first concrete evidence that women died in the violence of May 31-June 1, 1921. There is anecdotal evidence that at least one woman may have died as a result of injuries suffered during the destruction of Tulsa’s Black Greenwood District.

Stubblefield said her preliminary examination of remains disturbed in the process of uncovering them suggests teeth and some bones are in good enough condition that DNA testing is possible. Determining cause of death is uncertain.

On the other side of the ledger, Stackelbeck said coring samples taken at the so-called Clyde Eddy site about 100 yards east of the current excavation show no evidence of being a mass burial site.

Historian Scott Ellsworth, who has researched and written about the massacre for three decades, said: “This has been a hugely important week for the city of Tulsa, but more than that, for our country. This is the only time any level of (American) government has gone out to search for the hidden remains of victims of racial violence.

“This is an amazing event that’s happened here in Tulsa, and Tulsa is to be complemented for its leadership,” Ellsworth said.

In truth, the investigators cannot yet say for certain the remains are those of massacre victims, but the arrangement of the coffins and their location near two markers for men known to have died in the fighting is taken as an indication that is probably the case.

Brenda Alford, chairwoman of the citizen oversight committee and the granddaughter of massacre survivors, said she was “truly beyond words” in her excitement at the discovery.

“I don’t believe my grandparents and other members of the community could have ever imagined this time in history,” Alford said.

Mayor G.T. Bynum examined the grave site and thanked the City Council for standing behind his initiative to search for the unmarked burials. Cost to the city of the investigation is believed to have topped $100,000 over two years.

Bynum has said on more than one occasion the city owes the families of massacre victims to do all it can to find the remains.

“I want to thank the citizens of Tulsa for funding this work, for doing something previous generations of Tulsans wouldn’t do,” Bynum said. “The citizens of Tulsa … have essentially reversed a century of the conventional wisdom of this being something we don’t want to talk about, that we just want to put behind us and pretend it never happened. This generation of Tulsans did not do that. I’m thankful for that.”

Featured video: Researchers discover human remains in unmarked grave at Oaklawn Cemetery; further examination needed to determine Tulsa Race Massacre connection

Researchers discover human remains in unmarked grave at Oaklawn Cemetery; further examination needed to determine Tulsa Race Massacre connection

Tulsa Race Massacre: This is what happened in Tulsa in 1921


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News